2026-10-05 - NSF ACO Meeting Agenda & Summary

2026-10-05 - NSF ACO Meeting Agenda & Summary

Attendees:

John Towns, Amitava (Amit) Majumdar, Chuck Pavloski, Dina Meek, Kim Mann Bruch, Cindy Wong, Misha Shah, Sharon Geva, Ed Walker, Shannon Bradley

AI Transcribing is not allowed for this meeting due to NSF participation and their directives

 

Decisions made during the meeting:

Use Decision Macro

Weekly ACO–NSF Meeting Structure  

Items highlighted in blue are instructions for each section.

  1. Joint Program Updates (10 min) 

    1. ACO Program Updates (5 min) - John Towns
      Section content instructions: High-level summary of what changed since last week. 
      Metrics snapshot (usage, staffing, financials). 

      1. Staffing Report - no changes

      2. Financials - referenced in supplement

    2. NSF Updates (15 min) 
      Section content instructions: NSF perspective: relevant program, agency, or portfolio updates
      Any context that may affect ACCESS or ACO operations.

  2. NSF Action Items - (5 min) https://access-ci.atlassian.net/jira/core/projects/ATT/list?sortBy=duedate&direction=ASC&filter=status%20in%20(%22To%20Do%22%2C%20In-Progress)%20AND%20%22Category%5BCategory%5D%22%20in%20(Original-PEP%2C%20PY3-PEP-WBS-5%2C%20PY3-PEP-WBS-4%2C%20PY3-PEP-WBS-3%2C%20PY3-PEP-WBS-2%2C%20PY3-PEP-WBS-1%2C%20%22NSF%20Meeting%20To%20Do%22)
    Meeting tasks/Upcoming PEP Tasks

    1. image-20261005-135550.png



  3. Carryover Action Items (5 min) 
    Section content instructions: Review prior week’s decisions & commitments. 
    Confirm closed vs. still open.
    Note blockers. 

    1. none

  4. Critical Status & Red Items (10 min) 
    Section content instructions: Current or Overdue Tasks (top 3–5)
    Owner quick updates + path to resolution. 
    NSF input requested if escalation/decision is needed. 

    1. none

  5. Program Spotlight (5 - 10 min)  -
    Section content instructions: Brief look at one priority area each week (e.g., risk, staffing, allocations, milestones). 
    Goal: share context and keep alignment at the program level. 
    Detailed work continues in ACO team meetings — this time is for big-picture feedback.  

    1. Supplement Request

    2. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1AW3Cwl4rOn_MtsO1NqWJzEfe4Y2nTDmI/edit?pli=1

      1. no quarterly or EAB meetings in person - all virtual

      2. the awards will still exist for PY6 - critical operation will continue for all of the awards - it depends on what we have to do for the coordination

      3. SC/WG - may reduce some of the committees - look at them one by one - ex: we will not be re-designing the web site or making new personas

        1. Chuck will follow up

      4. Assistance with oversite - close out and reporting and materials for transition

        1. should we prepare for a transition package?

        2. Sharon - we anticipate that there will be transition planning that we will be expected to participate in - what exactly we need to hand off is currently TBD - we have a lot of the artifacts already

      5. EC - they each got their direction of what they should do - plan for risks and possibly new ones

      6. Communications - we may have to back off some - program stories are still important - communicate to the community what they should expect for the transition - may need more communications on that point

      7. Sharon - transition plan - bring that up in comms - we don’t know who will be taking up comms for the new operator

      8. John - but we don’t know who they will be

      9. Sharon - it may that we don’t need to do anything at all - transition date end of calendar year 2027

        1. Doesn’t know what deliverables should be - could be anywhere in the spectrum for amount to do

      10. Formal transition date - will there be a formal switch over date - depends on what the new operator wants to prioritize first

        1. This is making things challenging - if all we are doing is closing docs we may not need all the staff

        2. Sharon - this is a transition and not a cutoff

        3. But is end of 27 the beginning of overlap or the end of the overlap

        4. End of 27 is very vague - Sharon’s thought is it depends on the new operator

      11. When can we talk to the new people? Within months

        1. we are in Q1 of FY27

        2. there is a CR till Dec 11 - which comes with a prorated amount of money and a number of limitations

        3. hopefully within a few months

      12. EAB is beneficial for transition period

      13. Things to support the backend - we need to keep supporting the tools

        1. check to see what the other awards will still be using and see what we can trim down

      14. Sharon - if there was anything we are planning to do in PY5 which doesn’t make sense because we need to find out what the plan is for the new operator - we can have a no-cost extension

      15. John - we have targeted spending all our PY5 funds - we probably won’t need a NCE

    3. Supplement Budget - Spending in PY5 total est between: $1,923,034.18 and $2,038,254.78

      1. DRAFT Full Budget - $1,440,995.89

        1. Includes SDSC ask at $276,000.00 (current levels)

        2. Draft Full Budget: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1NWWAdK2Y0pFo-5trJ0dOctaFaqqEixi5QHKm2cV26hU/edit?pli=1&gid=0#gid=0 - Tab 1

        3. Draft Budget Request - Full Budget: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xYspF88xKnqzPVhKCdqmxp4OKX9eNIl8/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=108483074521788833672&rtpof=true&sd=true

      2. Draft Budget $750,000 with no Quarterly Meetings - includes reduction of staff - est: $778,825.43 at the moment – will reduce further to hit $750,000

        1. Comms: Megan Johnson and Andrew Helregel - 0%

        2. PM: Misha S - 0%

        3. PM: Shannon Bradley - reduced to 40% from 50%

        4. Gov: John Towns - reduced to 20%

        5. Gov: Chuck P - 0%

        6. Comms: Reduced Web Design Company agreement from $50,050 to $20,000

        7. Draft Budget: $750,000 with no Quarterly Meetings - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1NWWAdK2Y0pFo-5trJ0dOctaFaqqEixi5QHKm2cV26hU/edit?pli=1&gid=1075145002#gid=1075145002 - Tab 2

        8. Draft Budget Request - with no Quarterly Meetings - https://docs.google.com/document/d/12GHKwqKIwGayMzL8TBc92BZsjR36OU8h/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=108483074521788833672&rtpof=true&sd=true

      3. Draft Budget $750,000 with no PEARC, SC or Quarterly Meetings - est total $751,299.15 right now - will reduce further to hit $750,000

        1. Comms: Megan Johnson and Andrew Helregel - 0%

        2. PM: Misha S - 0%

        3. PM: Shannon Bradley - reduced to 40% from 50%

        4. Gov: John Towns - reduced to 20%

        5. Gov: Chuck P - reduced to 25%

        6. Comms: Reduced Web Design Company agreement from $50,050 to $25,000

        7. Draft Budget: $750,000 with no PEARC, SC or Quarterly Meetings - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1NWWAdK2Y0pFo-5trJ0dOctaFaqqEixi5QHKm2cV26hU/edit?pli=1&gid=2077238418#gid=2077238418 - Tab 3

        8. Draft Budget Request - with no PEARC, SC, or Quarterly Meetings - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UamB5hDQRch0A-sDCx8TbQhpaKgRjmfb/edit?usp=drive_link&ouid=108483074521788833672&rtpof=true&sd=true

    4. Sharon

      1. The number she provided is the number she has for the availble budget - prioritize accordingly - emphasis is close out and transition, de emphasize inperson travel or person

        1. End of '27 is when the transition will be happening

      2. There may have been activities that we intended to do in PY5 - we can still get a no-cost extension for any left-overs

      3. This is not a PY6 - it is a transition

    5. John

      1. This is a challenge - that implies that there is something that will be done by the new operator at some time - but we can’t plan on a nebulous date

    6. Sharon

      1. We are to focus on wrapping up things

      2. It is up to someone else to pick up things

      3. you can’t plan on things that will be something that someone else puts together

    7. John

      1. Challenge is the close out and transition requires us to know what we will be transitioning to and when

    8. Sharon

      1. We will know sooner rather than later

      2. Focus on the closeout

    9. John

      1. interpretation - we plan to shut down everything we have by the end of the award - which is not a trnsition

    10. Sharon

      1. She is getting varied info and interpretation

    11. John -

      1. Ongoing operations -

    12. Sharon

      1. Communications can be critical but there are other things that are not critical

      2. PEARC and SC - beyond critical path

    13. John

      1. So we have to figure it out

      2. PEARC and SC - the prior project held the booth for the next project

    14. Sharon - don’t plan for it

    15. John - if new operator wants to be at SC they will lose their standing

    16. Sharon - yes

    17. John - we will not reserve the space

    18. Sharon - don’t worry about anyone else

    19. John - he is worrying about the community

    20. Sharon - the community will not be dropped

    21. Sharon - at the limit of what she can offer for guidance

    22. Nikki - when we go to enter a supplement - she gets a warning that supplements can only be 6 months - looks like a warning that she can still submit - but is that OK

    23. Sharon - she thinks the people at research.gov could answer or OAM (office of award management) could help - they are pretty slammed right now but now is the best time to ask - look in award notices and Janelle Gosey (and LaShawn Farrior) is a good contact or anyone else on that would be good to email and CC Sharon

      1. Nikki - what about a help desk ticket?

      2. Sharon - best to start at OAM

      3. John will find the emails for Jannele and Rashawn - Gosey, Jannele L. <jgosey@nsf.gov>, Farrior, LeVar Rashawn <lfarrior@nsf.gov>

    24. Has to be in by Dec 1

  6. Other ECs got similar emails and are going to probably have to commit to the new finance directive

  7. Misha is being spinned down since we are no longer focusing on strategic planning - last week next week

  8. Updates

    1. Dina - sent some stories to Maria Pendleton, focused on SC

      1. Sharon re-does her copies of the Impact page every time the page is updated - this has been very valuable

    2. Shannon - working on PY6 supplement and budget, and starting some transition stuff

    3. Amit - eval committee - on track to send out in January

    4. Cindy - RAC recording will be ready soon for Sharon, EAB is Oct 28

      1. Sharon will try to participate in the first half of the meeting - has conflict for second half

    5. Kim - stories - UK and UM use Delta - focusing on smaller RPs and what they have been using their allocation for

    6. Chuck - EAB meeting - Tickets for EAB recommendations - down to 12 making sure we have followed up on them - scheduling interactive meetings with EC

    7. Sharon - remember our award ends at the end of April

    8. John - Lesson learned - we did not formally track recommendations as early as we probably should have - need to do a better job of tracking the recommendations earlier

      1. ACCESS Lessons Learned on Decisions Made: October - December 2026

    9. Lisa - still continue to be an observer - primary role going forward is helping the team process this transition - giving an outside opportunity to talk through and help make decisions and offer alternatives

  9. Wrap-Up: Next Steps & Action Items (2–3 min) 
    Section content instructions: Confirm owners + deadlines. 
    Recap today’s decisions. - Today's Decisions (top of the agenda)
    Identify materials NSF expects before the next meeting. 

    1.  

Additional Discussion/Update

Next Meeting: Oct 19, 2026