2025-04-15 ACCESS EC Meeting Agenda & Summary
Attendees:
RAMPS: Stephen Deems (v), Dave Hart
MATCH: Shelley Knuth (v), Alana Romanella, Jim Griffioen
CONECT: Tim Boerner (v), Leslie Froeschl
MMS: Tom Furlani (v), Joe White
RP: Jeremy Fischer (v), Eric Adams
EAB: Chuck Pavloski
OpenCI: John Towns (v), Amit Majumdar , Lavanya Podila, Lisa Kaczmarczyk, Shannon Bradley
NSF: Sharon Geva, Puri Bangalore
Guest Speaker:
Parking Lot
Missing Tom - cannot vote - we don’t have a quorum
will need to vote on 2 sets of meeting notes next week
March Quarterly Survey Results - postponed to next week
(v) indicates a voting member
Decisions made during the meeting:
Use Decision Macro - Tool (under Insert Elements in the tool bar)
Agenda
Consent Agenda @Stephen Deems (Unlicensed) (5 mins) - Please review
Approval of summaries from prior EC meeting
Informational Items
RP Forum @Jeremy Fischer
Allocations Stephen Deems
Lotta NAIRR Pilot UI work coming out
MATCH Shelley Knuth/Alana/Jim
CONECT Tim Boerner/Leslie
MMS Tom Furlani
EAB @Chuck P
Next EAB meeting: Cindy working on getting date settled for next EAB virtual meeting in June. Likely June 20th.
June/July EAB availability request sent to EAB, EC, and NSF. Deadline, Monday, April 14 (https://www.when2meet.com/?29726857-yYXPc)
Summary report to be submitted by Wednesday, April 30.
Pending results: 3/18/25 EAB meeting. Deadline to provide feedback Monday, April 21.
OpenCI John Towns
NSF Sharon and Puri
SC/WG Comms
Implementing SC and WG reports to EC - All six scheduled times are in place for this quarter and will be doing regular reports going forward.
Coordination / schedule document here:
SC/WG Coordination
Milestone Review
To Do / Follow Ups
Reminders
Annual Reports
Upcoming Meetings & Events (
ACCESS Engagement Tracker )
Additional Agenda Items
Overdue Milestones - please comment, update date, and/or resolve in system
Overdue Tasks - please comment, update date and/or resolve in system
Decisions on PEARC’25 Gold Sponsorship Opportunities (10 mins - Shelley)
Half-day Technical Workshop on Monday, July 21st
Workshop topic, summary paragraph, and speaker list due to pearc25-exhibitors@pearc.org by April 18, 2025
15-minute Exhibitor Forum Speaking Opportunity - Topic of your choice!
Abstract submitted to pearc25-exhibitors@pearc.org by April 18, 2025 for approval.
Dave will take over for Shelley for this one
Discussed possibilities - Shelley will wrap and collate ideas and we will get final approval via email
Shelley will email to Dina to handle turning in submissions or use link in email as needed
RP Meeting Debrief (15 mins - Jeremy/Shelley)
Meeting in Denver
Shelley will send out notes - all notes are being stitched together - should get out last week
Impressions: was great opportunity to chat - people are interested in doing this again - discussion on ticketing system was much shorter than anticipated - there is a need for concierge level support that was brought up - Skype awardees are able to work with RPs and they noted a need for way finding/user mentor - discussion on account creation (for leads/PIs on projects but we have not considered other users who are not PIs - this needs improved - Dave took some action items) - went smoother
Jeremy said the short discussion on ticketing system was because everyone is resigned to using it and waiting on the next iteration
Shelley has put in a request for monies to do this again
June Quarterly Meeting Dates (5 mins) - tabled - discussion next week
Calendar placeholders sent for June 9/10 - these will need updated possibly? do we want a Monday and a Tuesday?
Thanks to Joe White for volunteering to assist in the planning for the next meeting.
Need more volunteers to craft a virtual meeting based on current/past feedback
change up team members and give people
Should we handle this via email or wait until next week to discuss?
Shelley thought this was not going to be two packed days - and was going to be spread over the whole week
ACO - send topic by email to the EC so everyone is ready to discuss this next week - Shannon will send out
March Quarterly Survey Results (15 mins - All) - need Metrics here - postpone to next week
ACCESS March QM Survey Responses
Please review as a group (AI summary below)
AI-assisted Summary of Open-Ended Questions
🔹 Agenda Suggestions & Content Focus
Conferences Update: People are interested in knowing what conferences the program is attending or has attended. It’s a good way to show external engagement and relevance.
Real Planning over Recap: Multiple comments point out that “PY4 Plans” didn’t feel forward-looking. People want actionable plans, clear goals, and vision—not just a retrospective.
RP Involvement:
Invite Resource Providers to share updates on services/resources.
Suggestions include a dedicated 30-60 minute session or embedding RP input into existing segments.
Workflow Impacts: A specific ask to show how developments affect other tracks—helping teams adapt proactively.
SWOT Analysis: A SWOT for the project might help align on strengths, challenges, and priorities.
🖥️ Virtual Meeting Feedback
Zoom Fatigue:
2 long (5-6 hour) Zoom days were too draining.
2-hour sessions with no breaks didn’t work well.
Suggestion to spread virtual meetings over several shorter days.
Better Use of Format:
Focus on info-sharing over discussion—Zoom isn’t ideal for deep conversation.
Info segments should be short (≤30 minutes) to maintain attention.
Consider breaking up long presentation blocks with breaks or transitions.
Interactivity & Engagement:
Zoom discourages discussion; very few people speak up.
Suggestions: polls, quizzes, structured brainstorming to boost interaction.
Try new strategies to draw out quieter voices.
✅ What Went Well
Quick adaptation/pivoting was noticed and appreciated.
Value in the online session was acknowledged, even if it’s not as impactful as in-person meetings.
❌ What Didn’t Go Well
Many sessions didn’t follow the stated purpose or format (e.g., "What Everyone is Developing" turned into a recap).
There’s frustration that not following the intended structure diminishes the session quality.
Task Tracking - click to open
Misc Topics:
Shelley - NAIRR
User experience WG - sending out recommendations for user experience items - if you see it please review but you can choose or not choose them
Jeremy -
for meeting on 4/29 - there should be new RP by-laws to review - will be going out to email ahead of time - Shannon put in notes for 4/29
Next EC Meeting: 22nd April 2025
Reference:
Risk Register: https://access-ci.atlassian.net/jira/core/projects/RR/board
Project Change Request: https://access-ci.atlassian.net/jira/core/projects/PCR/board